Young Adult Materials Research Project

Index:

1) Fantastic Four: Books of Doom
2) Joker
3) Batman: The Killing Joke
4) Union Jack: London Falling
5) X-Men: First Class – Tomorrow’s Brightest
6) Ultimate Iron Man Vol. 1
7) Batman: Year One
8) V for Vendetta
9) Watchmen
10) Civil War: Iron Man
11) X-Men: Emperor Vulcan
12) Superman: Last Son
13) Batman: Snow
14) Green Lantern- Wanted: Hal Jordan
15) Superman: Red Son
16) Twilight
17) Sixteen Candles
18) Hackers
19) Detroit Rock City
20) Better Luck Tomorrow
21) Valley Girl
22) Girl Next Door
23) Kids
24) Nick and Norah's Infinite Playlist
25) The Wackness
26) Little Brother
27) Luna
28) Smack
29) Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants
30) Suburbia
31) The Outsiders
32) The Wanderers
33) TTYL
34) The Boy In the Striped Pajamas
35) To Kill a Mockingbird

1) Fantastic Four: Books of Doom

Brubaker, Ed. Penciler, Pablo Raimondi. Fantastic Four: Books of Doom Marvel Publishing Inc., 2007 ISBN 0-7851-1704-0

Summary

Go deep into the mind and life of Dr. Doom, one of Fantastic Four’s arch nemeses. Before he became Dr. Doom he was Victor Von Doom, a member of the Von Doom Gypsy Clan in Latveria. After his mothers and fathers tragic deaths, Victor became consumed with evil and wanted nothing more than his mothers “cold” hands embracing him, as she did when he was a child. His life work became consumed in creating an alternative universe but along the way the government wanted his mind to create machines of death. An accident causes Victor Von Doom to become Dr. Doom, one of the most evil and intelligent men, who will stop at nothing to get what he wants. After his accident, he escapes from the grips of the government, to Latveria where he would change his life and the life of others, encompassing all evil.

Critical evaluation

Ed Brubaker explores the evil mind of Dr. Doom that leaves the reader knowing who Dr. Doom was and who he is now, a villain. This background story gives a clear understanding of who Dr. Doom was and why he became the “man” he is today. The story is told from the point of the view of the villain, Dr. Doom, rather than the protagonist which is the story that everyone knows. Pablo Raimondi art captures the light and darkness of Dr. Doom, from his childhood to his descent into evil as King of Latveria. The art is dark and well drawn, and his layouts are easy to follow. Brubaker and Raimondi adaptation of Dr. Doom captures his original story well and introduces a twist at the end.

Readers annotation

Victor Von Doom was an ordinary young boy whose tragic events lead him to become the feared, Dr. Doom. A dark examination of the mind of Dr. Doom told from his point of view.

Information About the Author
Ed Brubaker, born November 17, 1966, is an American graphic novelist known to superhero fans for his work on DC Comics' Catwoman (2002) and Marvel Comics' Captain America and Uncanny X-Men. Brubaker's first work in comics was for the independent publishers Blackthorne Comics and Slave Labor Graphics for which he wrote and drew Pajama Chronicles and Purgatory USA. In 1991, he became a contributor to Dark Horse Presents. Among those contributions was the three-part serial An Accidental Death, which won two Eisner Awards in 1993. An Eisner award is an award for creativity in writing and illustration in comics in American Comic books. DC Comics imprint Vertigo published Brubaker's Prez, Smells Like Teen President in 1995 and four-issue series Scene of a Crime in 1999. Brubaker signed an exclusive contract with DC in 2000 and began mainstream superhero work on such series as Batman and Catwoman, a character revamped by Brubaker and artist Darwyn Cooke.

In 2003, Brubaker teamed up with writer Greg Rucka to create the Gotham Central series, which focuses on the Gotham City Police Department. In 2004, free from his contract with DC, Brubaker began to contribute to DC's competitor Marvel. Ed Brubaker has won many awards for his works, including, GLAAD Media Award for "Outstanding Comic Book" (2004), Harvey Award for "Best Writer" (2006, 2007), Eisner Award for "Best Writer" and "Best New Series" (2007.) Ed Brubaker’s first works with the publisher, Marvel, was a re-launch of the Captain America series, which received national media attention for it famous climax of the hero's death, Captain America: The Death of the Dream. His works have won him many awards and he is recognized for his unique takes of the original superheroes.

Genre

Graphic Novel- Superhero

Curriculum Ties

Booktalking Ideas

1) Write a first person talk, Dr. Doom tells his own story

2) Dr. Dooms dialogue with himself (1-5)

a. Cause of good to evil

Reading level/Interest age

T+: 13 and up

Why book included?

I heard from a friend that this was good.

Review from http://www.amazon.com/Fantastic-Four-Books-Ed-Brubaker/dp/0785122710

Controversial Subject Matter and Defense

Sexual Situations – Does not show nudity.

https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgY3qm8Cn6p4Ecw-hTdkjCniR8qcB_nIEPs-WX6q9QZQR-A1Xge8Z_Br_KGdE3LjItePCirg8of-dkkS3MZnPvKfhfznCGbXcIr_JujyyfslxdoI739k4qYMI6lx3uUbX5-fFqCiQy2YH0k/s400/SCAN0003.JPG

2) Joker

Azzarello, Brian. Artist, Lee Bermejo. Joker DC Comics, 2008 ISBN 978-1-4012-1581-1

Summary

Told from the perspective of Jonny Frost, a low level thug who is sent to Arkham Asylum to pick up the Joker. Frost becomes part of the Joker's gang and begins to assists him in trying to regain his former status as a high profile gang figure within Gotham City. By gaining notoriety again he clashes with notorious figures, such as, Two-face, Killer Croc, The Penguin and Batman. Jonny aids and abides the Joker in numerous crimes, including multiple murders. Jonny goes from petty crime to underworld notoriety he has always sought. Although he is afraid of the Joker he respects and idolizes him. Jonny begins to look at Joker differently once he begins to act in ways that Jonny does not find to be a ‘joking’ manner.

Critical evaluation

Joker is a deeply disturbing and completely unsettling work, a literary achievement that is a successful attempt to scratching beneath the surface of the Joker's unfathomable psyche. It is a hellish decent into the insides of the most foul and guilty city that is known as Gotham City, with its most unworthy of living citizens. Its straightforward plot and onslaught of extremely graphic violence, Azzarello and Bermejo's story somehow manages to achieve a level of delicacy rare to any Batman comic, let alone one that goes into one of the most ludicrous and sick minds graphic novels have ever known. Bermejo and Azzarello create a Joker that is a masterpiece of chaos, gore, grit, guts, and unimaginable insanity.

Readers annotation

Jonny Frost life of petty crime has led him to break out one of the most notorious enemies, the Joker. Jonny helps Joker receive the notoriety he once had before the Arkham Asylum by committing many heinous acts.

Information about the Author

Genre

Graphic Novel- Superhero

Curriculum Ties

Booktalking ideas

1) First person narrative – Jonny while he commits crimes with Joker

Reading level/interest age

15 and up

Why book included?

Is a must read about Batman comics.

Review from http://www.dccomics.com/dcu/graphic_novels/?gn=10157

3) Batman: The Killing Joke

Moore, Alan. Illus. Brian Boland. Batman: The Killing Joke DC Comics, 1988 ISBN 0-930289-45-5

Summary

A psychological battle between Batman and his arch nemesis the Joker ensues after Jokers escapes from Arkham Asylum. The Joker intends to drive Gotham City Police Commissioner James Gordon insane to prove that the most honorable citizen is capable of going mad after having "one bad day". Throughout the journey, the Joker has flashbacks of his early life, which gradually might explain his true origins. In one day, through many unfortunate events, causes Joker who was once average becomes insane. Once in Gotham City Joker kidnaps Gordon and imprisons him in an unoccupied amusement park, where he makes him look at his shot, paralyzed, and naked daughter in many different photographs. Batman reaches Gordon but the battle between the Joker and Batman begins.

Critical evaluation

The graphics and great story line create dark mood and a twisted theory that causes the Joker to become, the Joker. The graphic novel is filled with perfect transitions, allowing the story to easily flow between present and past as the Joker attempts to force insanity on Commissioner Gordon. Bolland's art does not repeat itself in the novel; it gives vivid depictions of the characters involved, almost natural. All faces show full expression, showing every muscle and wrinkle. Together Moore's rhythmic dialogue and Bolland's unrefined art create a unique story that captures the insanity and vulnerability of the Joker.

Readers annotation

Joker tries to prove his theory that a sane man can become crazy in one day by kidnapping one of Gothams honest men, Commissioner Gordon. Gordon must view picture of his helpless daughter in pain that will cause any ordinary man to become insane.

Information About the Author

Booktalking ideas

1) Tell the Jokers Joke p 52

a. what is the joker trying to prove? is it possible?

Reading level/interest age

15 and up

Why book included?

Review from, http://www.grovel.org.uk/batman-the-killing-joke/

Controversial subject matter and defense of ideas

Violence: The violence seen is not glorified but rather looked down upon.

4) Union Jack: London Falling

Gage, Christos N. Penciler, Mike Perkins. Union Jack: London Falling Marvel Publishing Inc., 2007 ISBN 0-7851-2181-1

Summary

London is being attacked by an army of super villains and it is up to Union Jack and his band of agents to bring the terrorist down and protect the lives of the innocent. The terrorist attacking London are part of a group called R.A.I.D. Those that are involved in the attacks are: Shockwave, Firebrand, Ecstasy, Boomerang, Zaran, Machete, Crossfire, Jack O’Lantern, Jackhammer, and the Corruptor. Union Jack leads, Sabra, and Arabian Knight, into a fight against the evil doers to keep London safe. All of the other agents are occupied fighting crimes in far away lands so it is up this group to bring down the members of R.A.I.D. and attempt to keep London safe for another day. Union Jack finds himself in a bigger issue and he would do what he can to bring justice.

Critical evaluation

Union Jack is the new and modern Captain Britain that will keep London safe and secure from those that wish to harm the innocent. He will stop at nothing to keep freedom and justice in his country, even if it means that he will bring those higher than him under scrutiny. There are many cameos of other Marvel characters into the plot line. Christos gives a comic book adaptation of terrorist events that are related to the real world. The super villain terrorists are no match for the superhero, Union Jack and his band of allies. Union Jack has no special powers but uses in wit and agile abilities to his advantage. The illustrations are bold, vivid, and easy to follow. It is loaded with non-stop action and working class heroics that makes Union Jack a fast and fun read.

Readers annotation

A band of super villains are attacking London and there only hope is Union Jack, Sabra, and Arabian Knight.

Information About the Author

Genre

Graphic Novel - Superhero

Curriculum Ties

Booktalking ideas

1) Dialogue between Union Jack, Sabra, and Arabian Knight (21-23)

a. Ask question, regarding situation.

2) Introduce Union Jack, quote from pg 1. describe his characteristics and which superheroes is he like.

Reading level/interest age

T+: 13 and up

Why book included?

Review from http://www.popmatters.com/pm/review/union-jack-london-falling/

Controversial Subject Matters and Defense

Racism – The Arabic Knight is thought of as being a terrorist but it is resolved once he fights off the real terrorist.

5) X-Men: First Class - Tomorrow's Brightest

Parker, Jeff. Pencilers, Roger Cruz with Paul Smith. X-Men: First Class – Tomorrow’s Brightest Marvel Publishing Inc., 2007 ISBN 0-7851-2426-8

Summary

Before they became the X-Men they were your ordinary group of teenage mutants. Being a teenager is hard enough but with super powers it is easier…not! Before Cyclops, Marvel Girl, Angel, Beast and Iceman became teachers at Xaviers School for Gifted Youngsters they were its first teenage students dealing with ordinary teen situations with an added twist of understanding and using there powers. They explore and learn to control there abilities through many difficult situations they find themselves in. This eight part sage tells the story of the original X-Men growing and learning through experiences that made them the superheroes of today.

Critical evaluation

It goes into depth of the main characters, Cyclops, Marvel Girl, Angel, Beast and Iceman, each having there own story. There personalities shine through and are a great mix filled with diversity, with distinct voices. The situations that they find themselves are laughable, giant lizard, man eating plants, etc. but the main plot of the story is to show there teamwork. Parker invites the reader into the teenage student world before they became the superhero X-Men that many know them as now. It is easy to read and follow, which is always a plus! Parker and Cruz give a fresh take on the X-Men, capturing there innocence.

Readers annotation

Before they became X-Men, Cyclops, Marvel Girl, Angel, Beast and Iceman had to learn about there superhuman powers at Xaviers School for Gifted Children through many interesting situations.

Information About the Author

Genre

Graphic Novel - Superhero

Curriculum Ties

Booktalking ideas

1) A first person talk from all 5 characters

a. Being a teenager with superpowers

Reading level/interest age

A: For ages 9 and up

Why book included?

Review from http://comicsworthreading.com/2008/02/21/x-men-first-class-tomorrows-brightest/

6) Ultimate Iron Man Vol. 1

Card, Orson Scott. Pencils, Andu Kubert and Mark Bagley. Ultimate Iron Man Vol. 1 Marvel Publishing, Inc., 2006 ISBN 0-7851-1499-8

Summary

It is a journey from birth to young adulthood for Antonio (Tony) Stark, also known as Iron Man. Raised by his father Howard Stark, owner of Stark Defense Corporation, after his mothers, Maria Starks, death. His mother was affected with a regenerative virus that was gained after a freak accident in the lab while Tony was in her womb. Shortly after her death, Howard quickly covered Tony in the same virus for 5 years, leaving him blue and hairless. For those years, Tony was always in pain but learnt to deal with it. Tony must be protected from other geneticist who wants to steal the code of the virus to be used in warfare. Tony is a genius with super strength and regenerating capabilities. When he is no longer blue and hairless he attends a private school where he meets loyal friends, explores his powers, and builds a protocol to his famous body armor. After an incident, Tony and his friends are taken to a “special” school for teens just like him. Later, Tony dwells into alcohol to deal with his pain but also realizes that his powers can be used to protect and serve, which leads him into trouble

Critical evaluation

Informative information on Iron Mans beginnings told through detailed graphics and brilliant prose. The character development of Tony Stark and his parents background are a great addition to the comic.

Readers annotation

A regenerative virus consumes Maria Stark while pregnant with her child, Antonio (Tony) Stark. Before becoming ‘Iron Man’ Tony Stark must keep him self alive from others, alcohol, and his impulses.

Information About the Author

Genre

Graphic Novel - Superhero

Curriculum Ties

Booktalking ideas

1) First person talk told from Tony Stark

a. Being isolate, having powers, in constant pain

Reading level/interest age

Parental Advisory: 15 and up

Why book included?

Positive reviews from word of mouth.

7) Batman: Year One

Miller, Frank. Illus. David Mazzucchelli. Batman: Year One DC Comics, 2005 ISBN 1-4012-0752-9

Summary

Intimate look on how Bruce Wayne became Batman and his relationship with Lieutenant Gordon. Before they became a duet they were individuals who wanted Gotham City to be clean of all the criminals. Gotham city is at its low with corrupted politicians, criminals lurking out of all corners, and prostitutes. Gotham is a typical Sin City that needs a hero. Gordon is out there fighting crime on his own while Bruce is discovering his role in the city that took his parents life. Batman is coming out protecting people, some politicians and police find him a threat while Gordon thinks that he is doing good but wants to know who the man behind the mask is. Underlying story, is of Catwomans appearance into the story line.

Critical evaluation

Great prose and old school style graphics create a Batman that would be loved by all generations. It is seen more from the point of view of Lieutenant Gordon rather than Batman it gives a more depth analysis of a strong relationship that keeps Gotham City afloat. Miller writes more thought dialogue rather than conversational thus creating a more of a connection between the two main characters. Both Wayne and Gordon have the same values and thoughts of Gotham City and are willing to put an effort to save it. Year One, gives details to Gotham City, Lieutenant Gordon, and Batman’s true colors with vivid graphics. Both want to help the city but need each other to keep from falling apart, neither could do it alone. Mazzuccheilli artwork captures the grittiness that is Gotham City. Some illustrations are black and white while others have some color but there is darkness to every illustration. The graphic novel gives a great background of the many Batman’s that follow.

Readers annotation

Bruce Wayne returns to a city that is overrun by criminals while Lieutenant Gordon has been living in it. Batman and Gordon must form a relationship to bring down Gotham City scum.

Information About the Author

Genre

Graphic Novel - Superhero

Curriculum Ties

Booktalking ideas

1) Gordons dialogue in pages 27-30

a. No Batman no Gordon? Discussion

2) Discuss Gotham City and its issues

a. Does there city reflect Gotham?

Reading level/interest age

T+: 13 and up

Why book included?

Review from http://comics.ign.com/articles/626/626667p1.html

Controversial subject matter and defense of ideas

Drugs usage, prostitution, crime, political corruption – Real world issues in cities that are trying to be taken down by vigilantes.

8)

Moore, Alan and David Lloyd. Artist, David Lloyd and Siobhan Dodd. V for Vendetta DC Comics, 1988. ISBN 0-9302-8952-8

Summary

A fascist and dystopian futuristic United Kingdom set in the 1990s after a nuclear war, that has left much of the world destroyed. “V” the masked vigilant anarchist is the only one working to destroying the totalitarian government through elaborative destructive events. "V" rescues a Evey Hammond, from the “Fingermen” who intend to rape her after arresting her for prostitution. After rescuing Evey he detonates a bomb inside the abandoned Palace of Westminster. V takes Evey to his secret lair, which he calls "The Shadow Gallery". Evey tells V her life story, describing her life after the nuclear war of the late 1980s. After the bombing the government is keeping a closer eye on the country. V continues his course of destruction by blowing up buildings and taking down those in high rankings, from bottom to top. The government is becoming more aggressive and V as well as Evey must be careful, before Fate notices.

Critical evaluation Moore and Lloyd create a terrifying portrait of totalitarianism and resistance, with its prose and illustrations. It captures the depth of both main characters as well as the society that it is in. V description is of a broken man who has had everything dear to him stripped away by the government. Evey portrays an ignorant young woman who lives life carelessly without taking a moment to think about the society and life she lives in. The illustrations capture the rigid life that totalitarianism is with its bold and straight lines.

Readers annotation

V is a hero vigilante that fascist United Kingdom is looking for. Evey is a young woman who lives life without questioning anything who is woken up by V in an effective but cruel manner.

Information About the Author

Genre

Graphic Novel - Superhero

Curriculum Ties

Booktalking ideas

1) Dialogue between Evey and V pg 120-124

2) First had narrative from V

Reading level/interest age

15 and up

Why book included?

Review from http://thealternativeone.blogspot.com/2006/04/graphic-novel-review-v-for-vendetta.html

Controversial subject matter and defense of ideas

Anarchism – In a dystopian world anarchism is the only outlet to escaping it; it is on the way to utopian

Homosexuality – Hinders on the idea of freedom; this fascist like that of Hitlers, want to eradicate all the wrong and the leave the write, history.

9) Watchmen

Moore, Alan, Artist, Dave Gibbons. Watchmen DC Comics, Inc, 1986 ISBN 0-9302-8923-4

Summary

In 1988, Edward Blakes, murder is discovered by New York City police but have no leads to a. costumed vigilante Rorschach decides to do some investigation on his own, what he gets is more than he bargained for. Edward Bloak, was once a superhero named The Comedian, who was employed by the US government. Rorschach believes that he has discovered a plot to terminate superheroes and begins to warn his old superhero friends, Dan Dreiberg, Nite Owl, Doctor Manhattan, Laurie Juspeczyk, Silk Spectre, and Adrian Veidt, Ozymandias. With the rise of nuclear war becoming more of an issue between Russia and the US, superheroes are needed. More important Doctor Manhattan who is believed to have the power to stop it but after realizing that he might be the cause of his loved ones death he exiles himself to Mars. Earth is left to battle on its own while the rest of the superheroes are paranoid for there lives. Earth and superheroes are in danger and there is little hope left for humanity.

Critical evaluation

It is not the ordinary superhero book because it does not have all the same elements as one. There is only one character that has superhero capabilities, Doctor Manhattan, who received his after a freak accident in a lab, which is the story for most characters. Besides him, most of the other characters have gadgets and wear costumes that create there powers. It is a great story line because it creates an alternative universe then our own but it incorporates elements from it. For instance, it shows JFK’s death but it was done by a superhero or Nixon never resigned but was reelected three times! Its illustrations are well done and very detailed. Gibbons and Moore create a novel that captures the reader with its brilliant graphics and excellent story line.

Readers annotation Set in an alternate universe in the 1980s the planet is on the eve of destruction from nuclear war. Rorschach and Dreiberg begin to question a fellow super hero who might be on the path of destruction.

Information About the Author

Genre

Graphic Novel - Superhero

Curriculum Ties

Booktalking ideas

1) Dialogue between Doctor Manhattan and Silk Spectre in Mars (157-161

Reading level/interest age

15 and up

Why book included? Hugo Award 1988

Controversial subject matter and defense of ideas

Rape – A struggle that leads the character to becoming stronger.

10) Civil War: Iron Man

Christos. Penciler, Jeremy Haun. Civil War: Iron Man Marvel Publishing Inc., 2007 ISBN 0-7851-2314-8

Summary

Two Story lines- Rubicon- the fight against Captain America and Iron man. Captain America and Iron Man were once close friends. Captain America taught Iron Man to fight and became his predecessor but after an altercation the two became detached. A fight ensues between the two that will change there friendship forever. In the Invincible, Iron man is gung ho for the new law that makes those with powers to register themselves but there are many who do not agree with it. They feel that they are placing themselves out there in the public’s eye which would be dangerous to them. A fight begins with many marvel comic superheroes against Iron Man and his strong beliefs.

Critical evaluation

Both story lines are a great contribution to the civil war series. The civil war between Iron Man and Captain America, has great prose and illustration. While Iron Man is fighting Captain America there are clips of them training together. This is a great contrast from one another, in one they are friends while in the other they are enemies. In Invincible, Iron Man has to fight other heroes when they strongly disagree with the law. Iron Man is shown as an ignorant character who does not want to challenge authority. Civil War goes into detail about the internal conflicts that are Iron Man.

Readers annotation

Two story lines in one graphic novel, both dealing with Iron Man internal war. Iron Man vs. Captain American and Iron Man vs. Marvel “anarchist.”

Information About the Author

Genre

Graphic Novel - Superhero

Curriculum Ties

Booktalking Ideas

1) Discuss Iron Mans relationship with Captain America and the battle that ensues

Reading level/interest age

13 and up

Why book included?

Review from http://www.ugo.com/channels/filmTv/features/vforvendetta/comics.asp

11) X-Men: Emperor Vulcan

Yost, Christopher. Penciler: Paco Diaz Luque. X-Men: Emperor Vulcan, Marvel Publishing Inc., 2008 ISBN 978-0-7851-2551-8

Summary

Gabriel and Alex Summers are brothers who are fighting against each other for the fate of billions in the Shi’Ar. Gabriel is Vulcan the Shi’ar emperor while Alex is Havok who is leading the rebellious Starjammers against his brothers rule. While there is internal turmoil from the brothers as well as in there world there is an outside force who is willing to destroy both of them. A new power emerges, known as the Scy'ar Tal, a race of aliens who were driven from their home world by the Shi'ar centuries earlier, and are now seeking revenge. Havok along with his band of Starjammers are forces to join forces with Vulcan to fight the war against the enemies. Throughout the fight, Havok is aware that his brother might turn on him so is always waiting to see when his brother will betray him.

Critical evaluation

In order to really understand this graphic novel the reader must read the collection of comics before this. The book does not give a lot of background information on Vulcan or Havok beginnings of internal conflicts. Besides the lack of character development the plot of the story is well done. Two brothers joining together to fight against a common enemy but one is still waiting for the other to attack. The Scy’ar Tal secret is the most interesting part of the story because it makes way for the other story to continue. It is not your ordinary X-Men tale because it takes place in a different planet but none the less it still holds vital characters of the X-Men series.

Readers annotation

Its brother vs. brother in the Shi’ar Empire but when an outside force appears out of nowhere both brothers must band together to fight against the enemy.

Information About the Auothor

Genre

Graphic Novel - Superhero

Curriculum Ties

Booktalking ideas

1) read the story of the Shi’Ar-there displacement and revenge- pg 31-34

Reading level/interest age

13 and up

Why book included?

Review, from word of mouth.

12) Superman: Last Son

Johns, Geoff and Richard Donner. Artist, Adam Kubert. Superman: Last Son DC Comics, 2006 ISBN 978-1-4012-1343-5

Summary

Superman, has grown up thinking that he is the last Son of Krypton, but he is in for a surprise. A young boy crashes into downtown Metropolis in a pod. Scientists take him right away to find out where and what he is. Everyone soon realizes that the boy possess super powers. When the boy speaks, Superman is shocked to find out the boy is speaking Kryptonese. Superman takes it upon himself to take care of the child, he quickly becomes attached to him and discusses with Lewis about adoption. They name him Christopher Kent which the boy is vey excited about since he has grown to love the both of them. Meanwhile, in the planet Krypton, three prisoners have escaped from the Phantom Zone, Non, Ursa, and Jor-E (General Zod). These three criminals were banishes for crimes of treason never to be released again. General Zod and Ursa are looking for there child, Christopher and will stop at nothing to get him back. A battle ensues between those from the Phantom Zone and those of the Justice League. Superman must try to save Metropolis and Christopher at the same time.

Critical evaluation

The plot line as well as the illustrations are clever and unique in the Superman genre. The best thing about the graphic novel are the 3-D glasses that come with it. When Superman is in the Phantom Zone, the pages are in 3-D so the reader is experiencing it the same way the protagonist is. The graphics follow great with the story line, when there is no evil present the colors are bright but when there is it becomes darker. Johns gives an in depth analysis of the reason why the three main evil characters were sent to imprisonment and why Christopher was an innocent who was still locked up. He also gives a clue that Superman and Lois both want a child…maybe in the future.

Readers annotation

Superman realizes that he is not the last son of Krypton and grows fond of the boy, Christopher, but his evil parents would stop at nothing to gain him back. Criminals from the Phantom Zone crash in Metropolis and create havoc amongst its citizens and it is up to Superman and others to protect them.

Information about the Author

Genre

Graphic Novel - Superhero

Curriculum Ties

Booktalking ideas

1) First person narrative of Christopher – different world, evil parents, who he wants to stay with

Reading level/interest age

13 and up

Why book included?

Review from, http://www.comicsbulletin.com/reviews/122046547399361.htm

Controversial subject matter and defense of ideas

Child Abuse – eludes to it but does not show pictures. It can be related to real life situation.

13) Batman: Snow

Johnson, Dan Curtis and J.H. Williams III. Artist, Seth Fisher. Batman: Snow DC Comics, 2007 ISBN 1-4012-1265-4

Summary

Batman needs help on an investigation so he rounds up Gotham City citizens that will help him find what he is looking for. Victor, a doctor, discovers that his wife has a tumor and is willing to try anything to stop it. He takes his wife from the hospital and brings her over to his lab where he tries to save her life but ends up killing her in a freak accident that caused her body to freeze. Guilt stricken Victor begin to see his wife and listens to her demands of vengeance. Victor tries to take his own life but instead is given special powers that he uses to wreak his vengeance.

Critical evaluation

Gives great in depth detail of the man comics have come to known as Mr. Freeze but the style in doing so is boring. It does a very good job of Victors development character of switching from the loving husband to the killing machine, Mr. Freeze. It also allows Batman to reach out to the community for help rather than relying on himself and Commissioner Gordon all the time. The graphics are not very dimensional and the prose have no unique style to them. There are many other authors and illustrators in the genre that will give it a much better rendition.

Readers annotation

Batman gathers a group to help lead an investigation. Victor, a scientist, attempts to save his wife’s life but in doing so kills her and seeks a life of vengeance that his dead wife “desires” becoming one of Gothams villains.

Information About The Author

Genre

Graphic Novel - Superhero

Curriculum Ties

Booktalking ideas

1) Narrate first person account of Mr. Freeze after his wife’s death

Reading level/interest age

13 and up

Why book included?

Read a review on http://www.batman-on-film.com/comics_snow_review_jett_2007.html

14) Green Lantern- Wanted: Hal Jordan

Johns, Geoff. Penciler, Ivan Reis. Green Lantern- Wanted: Hal Jordan. DC Comics, 2007 ISBN 1-4012-1339-1

Summary

Test pilot Hal Jordan was chosen to represent an intergalactic police force created by the oldest beings in existence, the Guardians of the Universe. After crashing he hears someone calling him but it was not a person it was the ring. He is now meant to protect earth and the galazy from every threat imaginable, armed with a specially crafted power ring that turns his determination into reality. Hal has been framed for murder and is a fugitive on the run from a legion of intergalactic bounty hunters and the new Global Guardians. He must clear his name and discover who put a price on his head as well as the reason why.

Critical evaluation

A classic fantastic super-hero graphic novel that is action packed with fighting scenes throughout its pages. It is easy to read and follow because its very detailed graphics and prose that will have those who have no idea of the Green Lantern understanding it. The Green Lantern’s powers are explained thoroughly and the background of Hal Jordan is explained well. The plot line is also brilliant because it take an ordinary young man who is given super powers because ‘the ring’ wanted him. He must fight off the old Green Lantern as well as those who followed him, which is a great storyline of “guilty until proven innocent.” Most superheroes are given there powers without a fight but Hal must fight to make is presence known.

Readers annotation

Hal Jordan has been framed for murder and he is trying to prove his innocence but encounters many bumps along the way.

Information About the Author

Genre

Graphic Novel - Superhero

Curriculum Ties

Booktalking ideas

1) Dialogue between Hal Jordan and Abin Surs 1-5 – where switch was made

Reading level/interest age

T+: 13 and up

Why book included?

Review from http://www.amazon.com/Green-Lantern-Vol-Wanted-Jordan/dp/1401213391

15) Superman: Red Son

Millar, Mark. Artist, Dave Johnson. Superman: Red Son. DC Comics, 2004 ISBN 1-4012-0191-1

Summary

Superman landed in Soviet Russia and becomes one with the communist cause against the Americans. Lex Luthor is his American arch nemesis who is married to Lewis. Superman will do anything to fight for the cause of the communist even taking over the country. Lex Luthor find traces of Superman DNA that he found on Sputnik after the crash in Metropolis which he uses to create a Bizarro clone of superman. Russia accidently launches a missle at the U.S. that Bizzaro stops but is the cause of his death which causes more tension between the countries. The US is willing to do anything to bring Russia down while Superman cares more about creating utopia in Russia.

Critical evaluation

A great adaptation of the ordinary American Boy Wonder story actually fighting for the ‘Reds.’ This plot and illustrations are a masterpiece that leave the reader flabbergasted at the end of the tail. It take everything conventional that Superman possess and creates an alternative universe with no loopholes, everything is explained and answered. It goes into the mind of Superman as a communist and the mind of Lex Luthor an American hero. Superman is no longer fighting against the communist as he did once before but is now fighting against the US. It also gives a different idea of what would have been. In the graphic novel, Superman spends money in fixing Russia from the inside instead of wasting money on weapons of mass destruction. Millar and Johnson give a great analysis of the different world it would have been if Superman landed somewhere else.

Readers annotation

Superman lands in Russia and begins to create an utopian society by eliminating poverty and giving to those less fortunate. While Lex Luthor, in America, is working on a device that will leave Russia diminished.

Information About the Author

Genre

Graphic Novel - Superhero

Curriculum Ties

Booktalking ideas

1) use internal dialogue when superman is vision an utopian Russia and contrast it to Luthors hate towards the Russians. Pg 58- 60 and pg 34-35

Reading level/interest age

13 and up

Why book included?

Review from, http://www.comicsbulletin.com/reviews/105193495923037.htm

16) Twilight

Plot Summary

Isabella "Bella" Swan, has just move to Washington from Arizona. Her step-father is trying to make it pro in baseball so her mother and him are traveling. Bella has to move back to her fathers who she has not seen since she was little. She is the new girl at her high school. The Collins, Rosaline, Emmet, Alice, Jasper, and Edward, are all adopted brother and sisters that stick to themselves. Bella is quickly intrigued by Edward who at first seems disgusted to be around he but eventually warms up to her. After Edward miraculously saves her from an accident that she should have died in, Bella beings to question who and what he really is. Bella and Edward find it really hard to stay away from each other; they are both lured by one another. Jacob, her childhood friend, is Native American and tells her a legend that causes her to inquire more about the Collins. Bella believes that Edward might not be human after all but a vampire. Bella is trying to live her life as a normal teenager but Edwards secret puts her life in danger but Bella does not care since she is completely and utterly in love with him.

Critical evaluation

Readers Annotations

Bella is your ordinary new girl in high school who falls in love with Edward, your ordinary vampire. Edward must protect Bella to keep her safe from "carnivorous" vampires.
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included

17) Sixteen Candles

Plot Summary
Critical evaluation
Readers Annotations
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included

18) Hackers

Plot Summary
Critical evaluation
Readers Annotations
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included

19) Detroit Rock City

Plot Summary
Critical evaluation
Readers Annotations
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included

20) Better Luck Tomorrow

Plot Summary
Critical evaluation
Readers Annotations
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included

21) Valley Girl

Plot Summary
Critical evaluation
Readers Annotations
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included

22) Girl Next Door

Plot Summary
Critical evaluation
Readers Annotations
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included

23) Kids

Plot Summary
Critical evaluation
Readers Annotations
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included
24) Nick and Norah's Infinite Playlist

Plot Summary
Critical evaluation
Readers Annotations
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included

25) The Wackness

Plot Summary
Critical evaluation
Readers Annotations
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included

26) Little Brother

Plot Summary
Critical evaluation
Readers Annotations
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included

27) Luna

Plot Summary
Critical evaluation
Readers Annotations
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included

28) Smack

Plot Summary
Critical evaluation
Readers Annotations
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included

29) Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants

Plot Summary
Critical evaluation
Readers Annotations
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included

30) Suburbia

Plot Summary
Critical evaluation
Readers Annotations
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included
31) The Outsiders

Plot Summary
Critical evaluation
Readers Annotations
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included

32) The Wanderers

Plot Summary
Critical evaluation
Readers Annotations
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included

33) TTYL

Plot Summary
Critical evaluation
Readers Annotations
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included

34) The Boy In the Striped Pajamas

Plot Summary
Critical evaluation
Readers Annotations
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included

35) To Kill a Mockingbird

Plot Summary
Critical evaluation
Readers Annotations
Information About the Author
Genre
Curriculum Ties
Booktalking Ideas
Reading Level/Interest Age
Challenge Ideas
Controversial Subject Matter and Defense of Ideas
Why Book Included